Hospitals in Erie County, New York
10 Medicare-certified hospitals, sorted by CMS overall rating (a national standard — not curved within New York). “Not rated” is CMS’s own suppression, never a judgment.
| Hospital | City | CMS rating | ER |
|---|---|---|---|
| Upstate New York VA Healthcare System (Western Ny VA Healthcare System) | Buffalo | ★★★★★5 | Yes |
| Kaleida Health | Buffalo | ★★★★★3 | Yes |
| Kenmore Mercy Hospital | Kenmore | ★★★★★3 | Yes |
| Sisters of Charity Hospital | Buffalo | ★★★★★3 | Yes |
| Erie County Medical Center | Buffalo | ★★★★★2 | Yes |
| Mercy Hospital of Buffalo | Buffalo | ★★★★★2 | Yes |
| Bertrand Chaffee Hospital | Springville | not rated | Yes |
| Brylin Hosp | Buffalo | not rated | No |
| Buffalo Psychiatric Center | Buffalo | not rated | No |
| Western Ny Childrens Psychiatric Center | West Seneca | not rated | Yes |
Data: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (data.cms.gov), last updated April 28, 2026. This site is not affiliated with CMS or any government agency.